Comparing Herodotus s The Sea And Essay - 2122 Words

Herodotus is accused by Edward Said to be progenitor of Orientalism. Regardless of this indictment, Said fails to observe the fundamental nature of Herodotus s division of the world. Accordingly, he describes the world in the binary of East and West. I contend that this ideal is unfounded in Herodotus s text, and instead, the known world of Herodotus was quartered. Hence, by edification of â€Å"Greekness† and it following anomalies Furthermore, these delusions are refuted by the agreement texts of Redfield’s Herodotus the tourist† and Munson’s Herodotus and ethnicity. I Before on embarking on Said misconceptions anent Herodotus, he avails himself of Euripides The Bacchae and Aeschylus s The Persians, which he argues in â€Å"The two aspects of the Orient that set it off from the West in this pair of plays† which are the catalysts of Orientalism, and accordingly, neither are Herodotean texts. Nonetheless, I will refute the occasions he to greater degree implicitly examines Herodotus. II In anticipation of the task in reviewing Said’s misconception anent Herodotus, a close elucidation of the quintessential nature of Redfield s and Munsons’s works pertaining to the matter of who in were and who were not Greek, alongside anomalies who percolated this permeable division. Redfield establishes the identity of the Greeks and that of non-Greeks, specifically, by their culture, denoted by three ethnological terms: â€Å"diaita, ethea, and nomoi† (98, Redfield). In their layeringShow MoreRelatedThe Battles Between The Persian Empire And Ancient Greece1360 Words   |  6 PagesThermopylae and Herodotus Wenxin Zheng Exchange student, Nanjing University, China Battle of Thermopylae, which occurred ten years after the Battle of Marathon in the first Bohemia War, is another famous historical clash between the Persian Empire and ancient Greece. In Thermopylae, Spartans resisted for days, blocked the powerful Persian army from conquering Greek. In BC 490, the Persian army crossed the Aegean Sea and landed on the Marathon plain in the first Bohemian war, encroaching the AthensRead MoreThe War From The Realm Of Myth And Poetry1267 Words   |  6 PagesTrojan War would inevitably have taken place, with or without Helen. He goes on to continue that the presumptive kidnapping of Helen can be seen merely an excuse to launch a pre-ordained war for control of land, trade, profit, and access to the Black Sea. All these accounts could be true but Eric Cline believes that the events happened and took place, he believes that the Trojan War is true. â€Å"The male heroes of epic poetry, Helen of Troy has been immortalized, but not for deeds of strength and honor;Read Moretheme of alienation n no where man by kamala markandeya23279 Words   |  94 Pagesin Sicily, he was made one of the â€Å"Probouloi† (special commissioners), mainly due to his widespread fame. From reliable contemporary accounts one learns that Sophocles was a handsome, wealthy man of great charm. He had friends like Pericles and Herodotus, the great Greek historian. The Victorian critic, Matthew Arnold, praised Sophocles as a man â€Å"who saw life steadily and saw it whole.† The ancient biographer, Phyrnicus, says that Sophocles’ life was happy and that he retained all his faculties to